cars site screenshot

Cars.com in 2026: Is It the Best Marketplace for Buying and Selling Cars?

6oRFAMAAAAGSURBVAMAy4m4dfW5g2UAAAAASUVORK5CYII=

Buying or selling a vehicle online has become more complicated as vehicle prices continue to rise. Manufacturer destination charges have increased 157 percent since 2023, with domestic brands averaging nearly $2,200 in destination fees during 2026. 

Premium models cost even more, including the Cadillac Escalade IQL at $2,895 and large SUVs like the Chevrolet Suburban, GMC Sierra, and Jeep Grand Wagoneer at $2,795. These higher ownership costs have made online car shopping platforms more important than ever for comparing prices and finding better deals.

Cars.com remains one of the largest digital automotive marketplaces in the United States. It connects buyers with dealership inventory and private sellers while offering tools that make researching, negotiating, and completing transactions easier. If you're wondering whether it's the best online car marketplace, the answer depends on whether you're buying, selling, or simply looking for the safest transaction.

Cars.com Continues to Be a Strong Marketplace

Cars.com entered 2026 in solid financial condition despite slower growth across the automotive industry. The company generated $180.2 million in first-quarter revenue, up slightly from $179.0 million a year earlier. Although revenue grew only 1 percent, profitability improved significantly, with net income reaching $5.0 million, up from a $2.0 million loss in the same period in 2025.

Dealer subscriptions remain the company's primary business. They produced $163.0 million, or roughly 90 percent of total revenue. Meanwhile, OEM and national advertising declined 12 percent to $14.3 million, reflecting reduced manufacturer advertising budgets.

The company also reported:

  • $51.0 million in Adjusted EBITDA with a 28.3 percent margin.

  • $33.5 million in free cash flow, a 42 percent increase year over year.

  • $359.6 million in available liquidity, including $64.6 million in cash and $295.0 million in unused credit capacity.

  • $455.0 million in outstanding debt and a conservative 1.8x leverage ratio.

  • A $90 million share repurchase target after buying back 3.8 million shares worth $32.9 million.

These figures suggest that Cars.com remains financially stable and continues to invest in its marketplace.

6GOLasAAAAGSURBVAMAfhlzdQoIi7gAAAAASUVORK5CYII=

Buying Cars Online Through Cars.com

Cars.com aggregates millions of listings from dealerships and private sellers nationwide. Buyers can search by make, model, mileage, price, location, fuel type, accident history, single-owner status, and electric vehicle availability.

One feature that sets Cars.com apart from many online car-shopping platforms is its Days on Lot tracker. Instead of showing only vehicle specifications, many listings indicate how long a vehicle has remained on a dealership lot. This information provides useful negotiating leverage since dealers often become more flexible on pricing as inventory ages.

The platform also includes the Carson photo search engine, which allows shoppers to upload a photo of a vehicle to find similar listings nearby. Someone who spots a vehicle they like can identify matching inventory without knowing the exact trim or model year.

Cars.com also supports virtual appointments and home delivery through participating dealerships, giving buyers additional flexibility during the shopping process.8C35o4AAAAGSURBVAMAtpFx4OSEAiAAAAAASUVORK5CYII=

Transparent Pricing Helps Buyers Make Better Decisions

Vehicle pricing has become a major consumer concern, prompting greater regulatory attention. In March 2026, the Federal Trade Commission sent warning letters to 97 dealer groups over allegedly deceptive pricing practices.

Cars.com addresses this through its Total Vehicle List Price policy, which requires participating dealerships to display advertised prices that include mandatory dealer-installed accessories and other non-government charges. Listings using "$0," "Call for Price," or misleading conditional discounts violate marketplace policies.

Although buyers should always confirm pricing before visiting a dealership, this policy helps reduce surprises later in the purchase process.

Selling Your Car Online on Cars.com

If you're planning to sell your car online, Cars.com offers two primary options.

The first is a traditional private listing. As of 2026, private seller listing fees are $0.00, allowing owners to advertise vehicles without paying an upfront listing charge.

The second option is the Instant Cash Offer program. Sellers enter their VIN or license plate number, upload photos, and receive an offer if the vehicle qualifies. After a dealership verifies the vehicle's condition, the purchase can be completed without requiring the seller to buy another vehicle.

Not every vehicle qualifies. Salvage vehicles, motorcycles, commercial vehicles, and certain older vehicles are excluded from the program.

Caramel Verified Checkout Makes Private Sales Safer

One of the biggest improvements to Cars.com is Caramel Verified Checkout.

Rather than leaving buyers and sellers to exchange funds and complete paperwork themselves, Caramel acts as an independent transaction platform that handles title verification, payment processing, and peer-to-peer car sale title transfer DMV requirements. 

It also simplifies private-party car sales with an active loan payoff by paying the lender directly before transferring any remaining proceeds to the seller. The Cars.com Caramel integration buyer-seller fees depend on the selected services:

  • Buyer self-registration: $95

  • Standard DMV registration: $195

  • Advanced DMV processing: $295

  • Seller wire transfer: $25

  • Instant Plaid payment: 0.50 percent, capped at $100

  • Seller cancellation after signed paperwork: $250

Traffic Shows Buyers Still Trust the Platform

During the first quarter of 2026, the platform averaged 25.8 million monthly unique visitors and recorded 159.6 million total visits. Although unique visitors declined 11 percent compared with Q1 2025, traffic recovered 19 percent from the previous quarter. Semrush also reported approximately 25.9 million visits during May 2026.

Visitors spend an average of 8 minutes and 32 seconds on the site, indicating meaningful engagement rather than quick browsing. Cars.com also receives approximately 56,000 monthly referrals from ChatGPT and 7,000 from Google Gemini, showing that AI-powered search is beginning to influence how consumers discover vehicle listings.

+Rj5ZsAAAABklEQVQDAG1r7+088RGXAAAAAElFTkSuQmCC

Is Cars.com the Best Place to Buy and Sell Cars in 2026?

For many consumers, the answer is yes.

Cars.com combines a large inventory, transparent pricing policies, free private listings, and secure transaction tools into a marketplace that serves both buyers and sellers well. Buyers benefit from the Days on Lot tracker, negotiating leverage, detailed search filters, and pricing transparency. Sellers benefit from zero listing fees and the convenience of Caramel Verified Checkout, particularly when selling financed vehicles.

No marketplace is perfect, and buyers should still inspect vehicles carefully and verify pricing before completing a purchase. Still, for consumers looking to buy or sell cars online, Cars.com remains one of the best digital automotive marketplaces for dealership inventory and private-party transactions in 2026.

Shipping a Vehicle Purchased on Cars.com

If you buy a vehicle from another state through Cars.com, AmeriFreight Auto Transport can help arrange its shipment. Open and enclosed transport options are available, along with door-to-door service (Location Permitting). 

There is no upfront payment until you choose a carrier. Shipping costs vary based on factors such as distance, vehicle type, route, season, and transport method. 

Get your free, no-obligation quote today.

Disclaimer

This article is for informational purposes only and is based on information available at the time of writing. Features, fees, policies, traffic, and marketplace services may change without notice. Cars.com, Caramel, and other third-party brands mentioned are the property of their respective owners. AmeriFreight Auto Transport is not affiliated with or endorsed by Cars.com or Caramel.


Arrow

Start your free quote

BOOK NOW & SECURE YOUR DISCOUNT
2
3

Related Posts

Information About Shipping Car Shipping Cost Across Country: What to Expect
Posted on Apr 16, 2025
Car Shipping Cost Across Country: What to Expect

Shipping a car across the country can seem like a daunting task, especially when faced with the varying costs associated with tran...

Information About Shipping Pitfalls to Avoid When Using a Tow Dolly for Long-...
Posted on Apr 09, 2025
Pitfalls to Avoid When Using a Tow Dolly for Long-...

Safe towing starts here. Learn the top mistakes to avoid when using a tow dolly for long distances, from proper loading to state t...

Information About Shipping The Best American Motorcycle Brands: Explore Ameri...
Posted on Apr 08, 2025
The Best American Motorcycle Brands: Explore Ameri...

Discover top US motorcycle brands for 2025. Explore sales figures, market insights, and expert analysis to find your perfect ride...

Information About Shipping The Most Reliable Used Car Brands
Posted on Apr 08, 2025
The Most Reliable Used Car Brands

Discover top used car brands built to last! Our 2025 guide reveals expert tips on choosing reliable vehicles, avoiding costly repa...

Information About Shipping The Cheapest Way to Ship a Car Across the U.S.
Posted on Feb 21, 2025
The Cheapest Way to Ship a Car Across the U.S.

Shipping a car across the U.S. doesn’t have to be expensive if you know how to minimize costs. Prices can range from $500 to over...

Information About Shipping 10 Top Alternatives to Car Rentals While on Vacati...
Posted on Jan 15, 2025
10 Top Alternatives to Car Rentals While on Vacati...

Not planning to spend your vacation lounging on the beach? You'll need a way to get around! Explore the best alternatives to renti...

1 2 … 25
Free, no-obligation quote

Ready to get an estimate from AmeriFreight Auto Transport?

Get your free quote online in minutes, or call us anytime and we'll guide you through it.