Call Us: 
Email Us: 
Most Reliable Used Car Brands: 2026 Guide
Looking for a used car that won't break down or drain your bank account with repairs? You're in the right place.
Some car brands are built to last well past 200,000 miles with minimal maintenance, while others need expensive fixes every few months. The difference comes down to proven engineering, quality parts, and smart design choices.
This guide breaks down the most reliable used car brands based on real data from Consumer Reports and J.D. Power studies. You'll discover which brands consistently deliver dependable performance and which ones to avoid.
What You'll Learn
The top seven used car brands ranked by reliability experts
Which specific models from each brand are the most dependable
Important factors that make certain cars last longer than others
Brands with a history of expensive repairs and frequent breakdowns
The top seven used car brands ranked by reliability experts
Which specific models from each brand are the most dependable
Important factors that make certain cars last longer than others
Brands with a history of expensive repairs and frequent breakdowns
Key Takeaways
Subaru ranks as the most reliable brand according to Consumer Reports' 2025 study, with models like the Forester and Impreza earning well-above-average scores. Lexus takes the top spot in J.D. Power's 2025 Vehicle Dependability Study with just 140 problems per 100 vehicles.
Toyota and Honda consistently rank in the top five across both major reliability studies, making them safe choices for used car buyers. These brands share common traits: conservative engineering, thoroughly tested powertrains, and shared reliable components across model lines.
What Makes a Car Reliable?
Before diving into specific brands, it helps to understand what separates a reliable car from one that constantly needs repairs.
Engine and Transmission Durability
The heart of any long-lasting car is a solid engine and transmission. Brands like Toyota and Honda build powertrains that can efficiently run for 300,000 miles when properly maintained. They use conservative engineering approaches with proven technology rather than rushing to adopt the latest untested features.
Affordable and Easy Maintenance
A reliable car shouldn't cost a fortune to keep running. Some vehicles need a $3,000 transmission repair at 100,000 miles, while others only require regular oil changes and brake pads. The best used cars have widely available parts that mechanics can easily fix without specialized tools.
Data-Backed Reliability Ratings
Organizations like Consumer Reports and J.D. Power track real-world data from thousands of car owners. Their studies reveal which cars hold up over time and which ones spend excessive time in repair shops. These ratings are based on actual owner experiences, not manufacturer claims.
Consistent Build Quality
Some manufacturers rush out flashy redesigns with new technology that hasn't been properly tested. This often leads to recalls and expensive fixes. The most reliable brands stick to tried-and-true engineering, refining their models gradually over many years.
Top 5 Most Reliable Used Car Brands
Not all cars are created equal. These five brands have well-documented histories of lasting beyond 200,000 miles with minimal issues, especially for five to ten-year-old models.
1. Lexus: The Reliability Champion
Best Used Models: Lexus RX, Lexus ES, Lexus NX
Reliability Ranking: Number one for used cars (Consumer Reports)
J.D. Power Score: 140 PP100 (Best overall, 2025 Vehicle Dependability Study)
Lexus leads Consumer Reports' used car brand rankings and tops J.D. Power's 2025 Vehicle Dependability Study with only 140 problems per 100 vehicles, far better than the industry average of 202 PP100. Lexus also earned a 98.3 percent score in the What Car? Reliability Survey, its seventh consecutive win.
The NX Hybrid stands out with a 99.8 percent score on What Car? Reliability Survey, while the RX and ES consistently score above average across major studies. These vehicles often exceed 250,000 miles with proper maintenance.
Why Choose Lexus: You get Toyota-level durability with premium comfort. When issues do arise, Lexus dealerships handle repairs quickly and often at little or no cost.
2. Toyota: The Gold Standard
Best Used Models: Toyota Corolla, Toyota Camry, Toyota RAV4
Reliability Ranking: Number two for used cars (Consumer Reports)
J.D. Power Score: 162 PP100 (Third place, mass market brands)
Toyota ranks just behind Lexus in Consumer Reports' used car brand rankings. The Corolla and Camry won J.D. Power’s 2025 dependability awards for the compact and midsize segments, and the RAV4 remains one of the highest-rated SUVs for reliability.
Toyota’s proven formula, conservative engineering, naturally aspirated engines, and long-tested transmissions create vehicles that frequently reach 300,000 miles. Models like the 2019 Corolla and Camry Hybrid also appear in Consumer Reports’ best used cars list.
Why Choose Toyota: Strong resale value, easy-to-find parts, and nationwide repair support make Toyota one of the least expensive brands to maintain.
3. Mazda: The Underrated Champion
Best Used Models: Mazda CX-5, Mazda3, Mazda6, MX-5 Miata
Reliability Ranking: Number three for used cars (Consumer Reports)
J.D. Power Score: 161 PP100 (Second place, mass market brands)
Mazda ranks third in Consumer Reports' used car brand rankings, and second among mass-market brands in J.D. Power's 2025 study. The 2018 CX-5, 2016 Mazda6, and 2020 MX-5 Miata all appear on Consumer Reports’ best used cars list. J.D. Power's 2025 study with 161 PP100.
Why Choose Mazda: You get sporty driving dynamics, high reliability, and lower prices than comparable Toyota or Honda models.
4. Honda: Efficient and Built to Last
Best Used Models: Honda Civic, Honda Accord, Honda CR-V
Reliability Ranking: Number four for used cars (Consumer Reports)
International Score: 96.6% (What Car? Reliability Survey, number one ranking)
Honda ranks fourth in Consumer Reports and leads the international What Car? Reliability Survey with a 96.6 percent score. The HR-V performs best overall, and the Civic and CR-V consistently earn strong reliability ratings.
Honda is known for fuel-efficient engines, low maintenance costs, and excellent resale value. While some 2016 to 2018 turbo engines had issues, later models resolved these problems. Naturally aspirated engines remain especially dependable.
Why Choose Honda: Hondas often run past 200,000 miles with minimal repairs, supported by decades of consistent real-world data.
5. Acura: Luxury Meets Reliability
Best Used Models: Acura RDX, Acura MDX, Acura Integra
Reliability Ranking: Number five for used cars (Consumer Reports)
J.D. Power Score: Above average (varies by model)
Acura rounds out the top five, blending premium features with Honda’s dependable engineering. The 2014 and 2016 RDX scored 79 out of 100 in reliability, and the 2024 MDX scored 80 out of 100, showing strong durability even in newer generations.
Acura’s tight quality controls and focus on long-term durability help their vehicles age more slowly than most luxury competitors. Buying used also avoids the steep initial depreciation common with luxury models.
Why Choose Acura: You get luxury comfort and performance backed by Honda-level reliability at a fraction of European luxury ownership costs.
Brands and Models to Avoid
Just as some brands excel at reliability, others are notorious for frequent breakdowns and expensive repairs. Avoid these brands when shopping for used cars.
Brands with Poor Reliability Ratings
According to Consumer Reports' 2025 study:
Chrysler ranks last overall (26th place) for reliability
Jeep ranks second to last (25th place)
Dodge ranks third to last (24th place)
These three brands consistently score at the bottom for five to 10-year-old used cars, with owners reporting higher rates of problems across all categories.
Models with Known Issues
Nissan Altima and Pathfinder: Nissan's CVT (continuously variable transmission) has a history of complete failure before 100,000 miles. Many owners report transmission replacements costing $4,000-$6,000.
Jeep Cherokee and Renegade: Newer Jeep models suffer from electrical problems, oil leaks, and transmission failures. The Cherokee's nine-speed transmission has been particularly problematic.
Land Rover Discovery and Range Rover Sport: While luxurious, these vehicles have astronomical repair costs. Electrical problems, air suspension failures, and engine troubles are common.
Dodge Journey: This model has a track record of electrical issues, engine failures, and suspension problems. Reliability ratings consistently rank it near the bottom.
The Bottom Line on Unreliable Brands
Avoiding these unreliable brands can save you thousands in repair costs and headaches. While some models may seem like good deals upfront, their hidden maintenance costs quickly turn into financial nightmares.
How to Find a Reliable Used Car
Knowing which brands to trust is just the first step. Follow these tips to make sure you actually buy a good used car.
1. Check the Mileage Sweet Spot
The ideal used car has between 50,000 and 100,000 miles. This range means the vehicle has plenty of life left but costs significantly less than newer models.
Be cautious of extremely low-mileage cars. Vehicles that sit unused for long periods can develop mechanical issues from fluids and seals drying out.
2. Always Get a Vehicle History Report
Never buy a used car without checking its history. Services like Carfax and AutoCheck reveal past accidents, flood damage, title issues, and maintenance records.
If a seller refuses to provide a history report, walk away. This is a major red flag that they're hiding something.
3. Get a Pre-Purchase Inspection
Even if the car looks perfect, have a trusted mechanic inspect it before buying. A professional can spot hidden problems like engine wear, frame damage, or repairs that weren't done properly.
Most inspections cost $100-$200, but can save you thousands by revealing issues early. If a seller doesn't allow an inspection, don't buy the car.
4. Look for Consistent Maintenance Records
A well-maintained car is just as important as the brand. Check for regular oil changes, brake replacements, and transmission fluid changes. A neglected car will cost you money regardless of how reliable the brand is.
5. Watch for Red Flags
Walk away from cars with:
Rust or frame damage (serious safety hazard)
Flood damage (causes long-term electrical problems)
Persistent check engine light (indicates major mechanical issues)
Mismatched paint or body panels (sign of past accidents)
Comparing Reliability: The Data
Here's how the top brands compare based on 2025 industry studies of five to 10-year-old vehicles:
Final Checklist: Making a Smart Purchase
Before you finalize your used car purchase, follow this checklist:
Verify the Car's History
Start by checking the Carfax or AutoCheck report. Look for a clean record with consistent maintenance history and no accidents or title issues.
Inspect and Test Drive
Have a trusted mechanic perform a pre-purchase inspection. During the test drive, pay attention to how the car accelerates, brakes, and shifts gears. Unusual noises or warning lights signal trouble.
Ask Important Questions
Ask the seller why they're selling, whether the car has had major repairs, and if there are any known mechanical issues. Vague or evasive answers are red flags.
Negotiate a Fair Price
Research the car's market value using Kelley Blue Book or Edmunds. If the vehicle has minor flaws, use them to negotiate a better price.
Complete Proper Paperwork
Make sure the title is clean and matches the seller's name. Read the bill of sale carefully and verify the VIN matches on all documents. Complete the transfer properly through your local DMV or a notary.
Final Thoughts
Choosing a reliable used car comes down to three key factors: selecting a proven brand, finding a well-maintained vehicle, and doing your homework before purchase.
Before buying any used car, always check the vehicle history report from Carfax or AutoCheck, get a pre-purchase inspection from a trusted mechanic, and verify maintenance records. The mileage sweet spot is 50,000 to 100,000 miles for the best balance of reliability and value.
Consumer Reports emphasizes that individual model reliability can vary from the brand average. Each used car is unique with its own history of use and service, so checking specific model year ratings is essential.
Ship Your Used Car with AmeriFreight Auto Transport
AmeriFreight Auto Transport offers top-rated and affordable car shipping services across the United States. We connect you with licensed and insured carriers to help ensure your used car arrives safely at your doorstep.
What We Offer
Whether you're moving across the country, buying a used car from another state, or relocating for work, we make car shipping simple.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is the most reliable second-hand car to buy?
Consumer Reports’ 2025 study shows Lexus models like the RX and ES as the most reliable five to ten-year-old used cars. The Toyota Camry, Honda Civic, and Mazda CX-5 also rank among the top performers.
Which brand of car is best for second-hand?
Lexus is the top brand for five to ten-year-old used cars, followed by Toyota and Mazda. All three maintain strong reliability ratings as they age.
What are the 10 most reliable cars?
The 10 most reliable used cars for November 2025, according to Consumer Reports, are:
2016 Mazda6
2019 Toyota Corolla
2018 Mazda CX-5
2019 Toyota Camry Hybrid
2020 Mazda MX-5 Miata
2021 Kia Sportage
2017 Lexus NX
Honda Civic (2014-2019 generation)
Honda CR-V
Subaru Forester
What is the most reliable car in the last 10 years?
The Lexus RX leads with a 98.6 percent What Car? reliability score. The Toyota Corolla and Honda Civic rank highest for compact cars, while the Toyota RAV4 and Mazda CX-5 lead among SUVs.
How many miles should a used car have?
A range of 50,000 to 100,000 miles offers the best balance of cost and remaining life. Well-maintained Toyota, Honda, and Lexus vehicles often pass 200,000 miles with proper care.
Are hybrid used cars reliable?
Yes. J.D. Power’s 2025 study shows hybrids experience 199 PP100, slightly fewer problems than gas vehicles at 200 PP100. Toyota and Lexus hybrids are especially reliable.
