The average passenger vehicle on American roads is now 12.6 years old. That number changes how people should think about buying a used car. The question is no longer whether a vehicle can reach 100,000 miles. Most modern vehicles can. The better question is how much it will cost to keep that vehicle running for another five or ten years.
Used car reliability has become one of the most important factors in the ownership equation. Repair costs have increased by 53 percent since 2019, mechanic labor rates commonly range from $75 to $130 per hour, and a major repair can erase any savings from buying a cheaper vehicle in the first place. For buyers who want long-term vehicle durability, reliability data matters more than marketing claims.

Which Brands Consistently Rank at the Top?
Consumer Reports analyzed more than 380,000 vehicles spanning model years 2000 through 2025 to calculate a Consumer Reports used car brand score. The results show a clear pattern.
Lexus leads all brands with a reliability score of 77 on a 100-point scale. Toyota follows at 73. Mazda ranks third at 58, followed by Honda at 57. Acura and BMW each score 53, while Buick and Nissan earn 51. Audi and Volvo round out the top ten with scores of 49 and 48.
The gap between Lexus and the rest of the field is significant. It reflects a long-standing strategy of prioritizing proven engineering over rapid technological change. Toyota benefits from many of the same design philosophies, which explains why the two brands consistently appear at the top of reliability rankings.

The Vehicle Dependability Study Reveals a Different Story
Consumer Reports focuses heavily on older vehicles. The J.D. Power VDS 2026 evaluates vehicles after three years of ownership using Problems Per 100 Vehicles (PP100). Lower scores indicate fewer reported issues.
The study surveyed 33,268 owners of 2023 model-year vehicles and found an industry-average PP100 of 204. Lexus again finished first with 151 PP100. Buick followed closely at 160 PP100, making it the highest-ranked mass-market brand.
The data also highlights an issue many buyers overlook. Premium vehicles averaged 217 PP100, compared with significantly higher scores among mass-market brands. Luxury badges do not automatically translate into superior dependability.
Modern Technology Is Becoming a Reliability Problem
For years, buyers worried about engines and transmissions. Today's reliability concerns often involve software, screens, and connectivity systems.
Infotainment systems generated 56.7 PP100 in the Vehicle Dependability Study, making them the most problematic category. Connectivity-related complaints accounted for another 24.2 PP100.
The most frequently reported issue was Android Auto and Apple CarPlay integration problems at 8.9 PP100. Additional trouble spots included:
Built-in Bluetooth systems: 5.5 PP100
Wireless charging pads: 5.1 PP100
Manufacturer app connectivity: 4.7 PP100
That trend helps explain why some of the most reliable used cars are not necessarily the most technologically advanced.
Gasoline Vehicles Still Hold the Reliability Advantage
Powertrain choice remains one of the strongest predictors of long-term reliability. The latest vehicle dependability study found:
Gas-powered vehicles improved slightly year over year, while hybrid, electric, and plug-in hybrid systems all showed increased problem rates.
Plug-in hybrids performed worst by a wide margin. The explanation is straightforward. These vehicles contain both an internal combustion powertrain and a high-voltage electric system. More components create more opportunities for failure.
For buyers prioritizing long-term vehicle durability above all else, traditional gasoline-powered vehicles remain the safest bet.
The Cheapest Used Cars to Maintain for Over Ten Years
Long-term ownership costs often reveal the best values in the market. Among individual models, some of the lowest projected ten-year maintenance costs include:
The Toyota Corolla remains one of the strongest choices for buyers seeking predictable ownership expenses, while the Prius continues to demonstrate that hybrid systems can deliver excellent long-term value when properly engineered.
The Brands That Make the Strongest Long-Term Bet
Reliability is rarely about finding a perfect vehicle. It is about reducing the likelihood of expensive surprises.
Lexus remains the benchmark for used-car reliability, backed by industry-leading Consumer Reports and J.D. Power scores. Toyota continues to deliver exceptional durability and manageable ownership costs. Honda and Mazda offer some of the strongest value propositions in the market, while Buick consistently outperforms expectations.
The most reliable used cars share several characteristics. They rely on proven engineering, avoid unnecessary complexity, keep repair costs reasonable, and continue to perform long after many competitors have become financial liabilities.
Shipping a Reliable Used Car
The best used vehicle isn't always located nearby. If you find a well-maintained model in another state, AmeriFreight Auto Transport can help arrange transportation through vetted carriers.
Open and enclosed transport options are available, along with Door-to-Door Service (Location Permitting). Plus, there's no upfront payment until you choose a carrier, giving you flexibility as you secure the right vehicle.
Get your free, no obligation quote today.
Disclaimer
This article is for informational purposes only. Vehicle reliability, maintenance costs, and repair frequency vary by model year, mileage, maintenance history, driving conditions, and individual vehicle condition. Buyers should conduct their own research and obtain a professional inspection before purchasing a used vehicle. AmeriFreight Auto Transport provides vehicle transportation services only and does not endorse specific vehicle brands or models.
