You’re here because you want to know how to buy a used car on AutoTrader—and make sure it’s worth every penny. That’s the right move, especially now that the used car market is booming and prices can swing fast.
Online car listings in Autotrader can often appear attractive, offering low mileage, appealing photos, and seemingly great prices. However, like with any private seller exchange, you must be aware of what to watch out for. You need to know how to use the platform correctly, how to verify the true car value, and how to protect yourself when the deal seems too good to be true.
What You’ll Learn in This Guide
In this guide, you will learn:
How to safely buy a used car on AutoTrader from both dealers and private sellers
Tips to spot scams, verify car value, and avoid costly mistakes
Step-by-step guidance from research to final purchase and registration
Overview
What Is AutoTrader and How Does It Work?
If you're buying a car online for the first time, you're probably wondering: how does AutoTrader work—and can I trust it? The short answer? Yes, AutoTrader is legit. However, it operates more like a middleman than a dealership, so you’ll need to do some research before making a purchase.
Here’s how AutoTrader works in plain terms:
Sellers create listings with photos, mileage, price, VIN, and a written description.
Buyers search and filter listings by make, model, year, features, mileage, and location.
AutoTrader connects both sides, but doesn’t handle the sale itself.
This means AutoTrader doesn’t own the cars, set the prices, or offer guarantees. That’s up to the seller—whether it’s a dealership or a private party.
Two types of listings you’ll see:
Dealer Listings: Often include warranties, financing options, and certified pre-owned vehicles.
Private Seller Listings: Often priced lower, but require extra care and more checks.
Dealer Listings: Often include warranties, financing options, and certified pre-owned vehicles.
Private Seller Listings: Often priced lower, but require extra care and more checks.
If you’ve asked, “Is AutoTrader legit?” the answer is yes—but it’s up to you to verify the details and make an informed decision.
AutoTrader vs. CarGurus vs. TrueCar: What’s the Difference?
Not all used car platforms operate in the same manner. If you’ve used CarGurus or TrueCar, you’ve seen how each one takes a different approach to listings and pricing.
Quick Comparison Table
AutoTrader supports both dealer and private seller exchange listings, which gives you more choices. That’s a big reason shoppers often search AutoTrader vs. CarGurus together, but AutoTrader wins if you want more control and more types of listings.
Finding the Best Deals in Today’s Used Car Market
The used car market has undergone rapid changes. Prices are up, supply is down, and buyers need sharper tools.
AutoTrader makes it easier to spot a cheap new car or a well-priced used model by giving you the right filters and price alerts.
Here’s how to find better deals:
Sort by lowest price to filter out overpriced listings
Set price drop alerts so you’re notified as soon as sellers adjust their prices
Watch for “Great Deal” tags based on pricing trends
Compare listings side-by-side to find the best value
Price tags alone don’t tell the whole story. Always compare mileage, accident history, and owner notes before clicking "Contact Seller."
How to Determine the True Car Value Before You Buy
Overpaying is easy, especially when listings are marked up. Knowing the true car value gives you a competitive edge.
Here’s how to find out what a car is worth:
Use AutoTrader’s vehicle valuation feature
Cross-check with Kelley Blue Book and TrueCar
Look out for unusually low prices—they may come with hidden problems
Ask questions that match the price to the car’s condition:
What’s the mileage?
Any past accidents?
Is there a full service record?
Use this info to negotiate or walk away when the numbers don’t add up.
How to Safely Buy from a Private Seller on AutoTrader
Buying from a private seller through AutoTrader’s private seller exchange can be a great deal, but you’ve got to stay sharp.
Your safety checklist:
Get the VIN and check the history on Carfax or AutoCheck
Always see the car in person, ideally with a mechanic
Meet in a public space like a police station or DMV parking lot
Verify the title and ownership
Use a bill of sale—never skip the paperwork
Don’t pay cash unless you have full documentation
Get the VIN and check the history on Carfax or AutoCheck
Always see the car in person, ideally with a mechanic
Meet in a public space like a police station or DMV parking lot
Verify the title and ownership
Use a bill of sale—never skip the paperwork
Don’t pay cash unless you have full documentation
How to Buy a Used Car on AutoTrader?
Step 1: Define Your Needs and Budget
Before diving into the vast inventory on AutoTrader, it’s crucial to establish clear criteria:
Identify Your Needs: Consider factors like car type (sedan, SUV, etc.), necessary features (e.g., fuel efficiency, safety), and acceptable mileage.
Example: If you have a family, you might prioritize safety features and ample cargo space, while someone commuting long distances might focus on fuel efficiency.
Set Your Budget: Consider not only the purchase price but also additional costs, such as insurance, maintenance, and registration. Decide whether you’ll pay in cash or finance the purchase.
Tip: Use online calculators to estimate monthly payments if financing. Set a firm maximum based on what you can comfortably afford, taking into account other financial commitments.
Why This Matters: A clear understanding of your needs and budget helps streamline your search, preventing costly mistakes and ensuring you find a vehicle that fits both your lifestyle and financial situation.
Step 2: Research and Narrow Down Your Options
Research is key to finding the right car. Here’s how to make the most of AutoTrader’s tools:
Use AutoTrader’s Filters Effectively:
Price Range: Set a maximum price slightly above your budget to account for negotiations.
Mileage: Consider the average annual mileage (approximately 12,000 miles per year) to gauge the extent of wear the car has endured.
Vehicle Condition: Filter by “Certified Pre-Owned” if you want a car that comes with a dealership-backed warranty.
Example: Suppose you’re looking for a 2017 Toyota Camry with under 60,000 miles. Start by setting your price range slightly above what you’re willing to pay, say $20,000, to see what’s available. Narrow it down further by specifying your desired mileage and selecting the “Accident-Free” option.
Evaluate Listings Carefully:
Photos: Look for clear, detailed images from multiple angles. Beware of listings with only a few or low-quality photos.
Descriptions: Read through the description for mentions of recent maintenance or any known issues. Listings that mention a clean title, regular maintenance, or recent repairs are often more trustworthy.
Check Vehicle History Reports:
Accident History: Prior accidents can affect a car’s long-term reliability and resale value.
Ownership History: Multiple owners or frequent sales can be red flags.
Service Records: Regular maintenance is a good indicator of a well-kept vehicle.
Tools to Use: Access Carfax or AutoCheck reports directly from the listing to verify the car’s history. These reports often include estimated market values, helping you gauge whether the asking price is fair.
Why This Matters: Using these tools effectively helps you avoid cars with hidden problems and ensures that you’re getting a fair deal. Thorough research is your best defense against buyer’s remorse.
Step 3: Contact the Seller
Engaging with the seller is a critical step in the buying process. Here’s how to do it right:
Start the Dialogue:
Be polite and professional. Inquire about the car's availability and express your interest. Mention specific aspects of the car that caught your attention.
Example Message: “Hi, I’m interested in your 2017 Honda CR-V listed on AutoTrader. It appears to be in great condition, and I appreciate the detailed description. Is it still available?”
Ask Detailed Questions:
“Why are you selling the car?” This can give insight into potential issues or just life changes for the seller.
“Has the car been involved in any accidents?” Even minor accidents can affect a car’s value.
“What is the current condition of the car?” Ask about any known mechanical issues, the condition of the tires, and when the last service was performed.
Red Flags: If the seller is evasive or provides inconsistent information, proceed with caution.
Why This Matters: Effective communication can reveal important details about the car and the seller’s reliability. This step is crucial for ensuring you’re making a sound purchase.
Step 4: Arrange for an Inspection and Test Drive
Seeing the car in person and having it inspected is non-negotiable. Here are some tips:
Monitor Different Factors During the Drive:
Engine Performance: Listen for unusual noises during startup and acceleration.
Brakes: Test the brakes at various speeds to ensure they respond promptly and don’t make noise.
Steering and Suspension: The car should handle smoothly without pulling to one side.
Interior Features: Verify the functionality of the air conditioning, radio, lights, and other electronic components.
Example: During the test drive, pay attention to how the car drives on both city streets and highways. Make note of any unusual sounds or vibrations, as these could indicate underlying issues.
Identify Possible Issues:
Tire Wear: Uneven wear can indicate alignment issues.
Brake Pads and Rotors: Worn pads or damaged rotors can lead to costly repairs.
Under the Hood: Check for fluid leaks, corrosion, and the condition of the belts.
Under the Car: Look for rust or damage to the frame and exhaust system.
Get a Pre-Purchase Inspection:
Hire a trusted mechanic to perform a thorough inspection. They’ll check for signs of previous damage, worn-out parts, and potential future issues.
Why This Matters: A comprehensive inspection and test drive can prevent you from buying a car that may require expensive repairs soon after purchase. It’s an investment in peace of mind.
Step 5: Negotiate the Price
Negotiation is where your research pays off. Here’s a step-by-step strategy to find the price:
Research Market Value: Use Kelley Blue Book or NADA Guides to determine the car’s fair market value based on its condition, mileage, and location.
Start with a Reasonable Offer: Begin slightly below the market value, giving you room to negotiate.
Highlight Findings: Use the vehicle’s history report or inspection findings as leverage. If the car needs new tires or has minor cosmetic issues, mention these as reasons for a lower price.
Be Prepared to Walk Away: If the seller isn’t willing to negotiate a fair price, don’t hesitate to leave the deal.
Example: Suppose the car is listed at $15,000, but your research shows its market value is closer to $13,500. Start with an offer of $13,000, citing any necessary repairs or maintenance as reasons for the lower price.
Why This Matters: A structured approach to negotiation helps ensure you don’t overpay for the car. Remember, the goal is to reach a fair price for both you and the seller.
Step 6: Secure Financing (If Needed)
If you’re not paying cash, you’ll need to explore financing options. Here are some key points to consider:
Check Loan Term Lengths:
Shorter Terms (36-48 months): Higher monthly payments but less interest over time.
Longer Terms (60-72 months): Lower monthly payments but higher overall interest costs.
Expert Advice: Avoid financing terms longer than 60 months whenever possible, as they can result in paying more in interest and facing negative equity (owing more than the car is worth).
Get Pre-Approved:
Pre-approval gives you a clearer budget and strengthens your negotiating position with the seller.
Compare interest rates from banks, credit unions, and dealerships to find the best deal.
Understand Key Terms:
Interest Rate: The lower, the better. Even a slight difference in percentage points can save you hundreds over the life of the loan.
Total Cost: Look at the total amount you’ll pay by the end of the term, not just the monthly payment.
Why This Matters: Financing decisions can significantly impact the overall cost of your car. Being informed about loan terms and interest rates ensures you don’t end up paying more than necessary.
Step 7: Complete the Paperwork
Finalizing the sale involves several necessary steps:
Gather Essential Paperwork:
Title Transfer: The title proves ownership. Ensure it’s transferred to you correctly.
Bill of Sale: This document records the transaction, including the sale price and any agreed-upon conditions.
Odometer Disclosure Statement: Federal law requires this for cars less than 10 years old to confirm the accuracy of the mileage.
Verify State-Specific Requirements: Please check with your local Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) for any additional paperwork or fees required in your state.
Avoid Scams:
Be cautious of sellers who rush the transaction or request payment via unconventional methods, such as wire transfers. Stick to secure payment methods, such as cashier’s checks or an escrow service.
Why This Matters: Properly completing the paperwork is essential for a legally secure transfer of ownership and protection against fraud. It ensures all aspects of the sale are documented and legitimate.
Step 8: Arrange for Insurance and Registration
Before hitting the road, you need to ensure your new car is both insured and registered:
Choose the Right Insurance:
Coverage Levels: Liability insurance is mandatory, but consider comprehensive and collision coverage, especially for newer vehicles.
Shopping Around: Get quotes from multiple providers to find the best deal. Online comparison tools can make this process easier.
Register the Vehicle:
Visit your local DMV with the necessary documents, including the signed title, bill of sale, and proof of insurance. Some states allow online registration, streamlining the process.
Complete Registration Promptly:
Each state has specific deadlines for registering a newly purchased vehicle. Failing to register on time can result in penalties and fines.
Why This Matters: Insurance and registration are legal requirements. Properly handling these ensures you’re fully compliant with state laws and protected in case of accidents or theft.
Step 9: Finalize the Purchase and Take Delivery
With everything in place, you’re ready to complete the transaction and take possession of your new car. Here are suggestions to reach that peace of mind:
Place Final Payment:
Ensure all conditions are met before making the final payment. If paying by cashier’s check, bring it with you to the final meeting with the seller.
Conduct Final Inspection:
Before driving away, do one last inspection to confirm everything is as agreed. This is your last opportunity to address any issues with the seller.
Set Up the Car:
If transferring license plates, do so immediately. Set up your in-car systems, such as Bluetooth, GPS, and other electronics, to your preferences.
Why This Matters: Completing the final steps with care ensures a smooth transition and allows you to start enjoying your new car without any hitches.
Final Thoughts: Maximizing AutoTrader’s Services
Buying a used car on AutoTrader can be a rewarding experience, provided you follow a careful and informed approach. From defining your needs to negotiating a fair price and completing the necessary paperwork, each step is crucial to ensuring you end up with a vehicle that meets your expectations and fits your budget.
You may also check out additional resources for better guidance:
AutoTrader Guides: For more tips on buying used cars, visit AutoTrader’s official website.
Kelley Blue Book: Research car values and get pricing advice.
Carfax: Obtain vehicle history reports to ensure a sound purchase.
Ship Your Car with AmeriFreight Car Shipping
If you're purchasing a car from an out-of-state seller, consider using AmeriFreight Car Shipping for reliable and affordable car shipping services. We have more than two decades of experience in the auto transport industry, ensuring that we know how to handle your cars with professionalism.
Get your free instant quote now.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
How can I verify the car’s history?
Use Carfax or AutoCheck to obtain a detailed vehicle history report. These reports provide information on past accidents, title issues, and maintenance records, helping you make an informed decision.
What if the deal falls through?
If the deal doesn’t work out, don’t be discouraged. It’s better to pass on a car than to rush into a bad deal. Use what you’ve learned to refine your search criteria and keep looking.
Should I buy from a private seller or a dealership?
Private sellers often have lower prices, but dealerships may offer warranties and more robust consumer protections. Decide based on your comfort level and the specific car you’re interested in.
Can I return a used car if I’m not satisfied?
Return policies vary. Private sales are typically final, although some dealerships may offer a return window. Always clarify the return policy before making a purchase.
How can I ensure the car I buy is a good deal?
Research the car’s market value, get a pre-purchase inspection, and use the findings to negotiate a fair price. Tools like Kelley Blue Book can provide a reliable benchmark for the car’s value.
